Beyond "Wallowing": A Bereaved Mother and Counselor Challenges Dangerous Misconceptions About Child Loss

No Comments

September 2, 2026

There are numerous deep-seated misconceptions surrounding grief, particularly when it involves the devastating loss of a child. These societal misunderstandings do far more than simply perpetuate unhelpful and rigid narratives; they can actively complicate the healing process for bereaved parents who are already navigating unimaginable pain.

Melissa Caffrey, a Licensed Professional Counselor and bereaved mother, knows this reality intimately. She will never forget the first time she and her husband, Jeff, sought professional therapy following the tragic accident that took the life of their son, Colten, who was six years old.

It had been just four weeks since they lost him, and the couple was ready to explore outside support. As counselors themselves, both Melissa and Jeff understood the critical importance of finding someone to simply hold space for them—someone who could guide them gently through the raw, uncharted, and terrifying territory of profound grief. What they encountered instead, however, was a series of significant missteps from a well-meaning mental health professional who ultimately failed to understand the true nature of their experience.

One of the most painful moments during that early counseling session came when they were told, with alarming bluntness, that at some point they would need to "stop wallowing."

For a grieving parent, hearing the word "wallowing" feels like a physical blow. Nothing could have been further from the truth. Jeff and Melissa were not wallowing; they were grieving the most profound loss imaginable, and they had made deliberate, intentional choices to focus on their emotional and physical healing.

In the wake of the tragedy, both parents had taken intentional time off from work. This decision was made not only because their profession as counselors demanded a level of emotional presence and clinical care they simply could not provide at the time, but also because they desperately needed physical and mental space to process their trauma and begin navigating their new reality. They chose to spend those first two months entirely within their home, surrounded by their adult children.

This environment created a safe space to grieve, remember, and adjust before they ever attempted to reenter the outside world. It was never about shutting themselves away from reality or avoiding the world; rather, it was about deciding how they would adapt to their new, shattered reality on their own terms, long before allowing outside society to impose its timeline or expectations upon them.

During those initial months, the family surrounded themselves with everything that reminded them of Colten. His personal belongings transformed into precious artifacts of his short life—tangible symbols of the memories his parents were desperate to preserve. It was an experience defined by deep heartbreak and bittersweet reflection. There were moments of uncontrollable sadness, moments when the emotional pain felt so acute and physical that it nearly brought Melissa to her knees.

It’s Not Wallowing: The Truth About Grieving a Child

The physical toll of grief was measurable. Melissa wore her Fitbit during those early weeks and noticed that her resting heart rate remained elevated by an average of 10 beats per minute, even when she was entirely still and resting. Grief, she realized, was never just an emotional state; it was an all-consuming physical force that impacted every system of the body.

Yet, amidst the overwhelming devastation, there were also fleeting moments of joy and laughter. They were quiet and muted, resembling echoes of a life they used to know, but they existed nonetheless. These instances served as tiny glimmers of hope—small, vital reminders that someday, life might consist of more than mere survival. The family shared stories about Colten, laughed at memories that naturally brought smiles to their faces, and found deep comfort simply by being together in the same room. They talked openly about how to honor his memory and carry him forward with them in a way that felt meaningful and intentional.

Those initial months were the opposite of wallowing. They represented a vital period to begin carving out a new normal—to grieve deeply and unreservedly, yes, but also to start envisioning a future where they could carry Colten with them within their hearts forever. Grief, as Caffrey emphasizes, is not something an individual simply "gets over." Instead, it is something a person learns to carry. Taking that time together as a family proved to be one of the most constructive steps they could have taken for their healing.

The reality remains that grief is profoundly exhausting. It is physical, emotional, and relentless. Individuals who have never experienced this level of loss often fail to comprehend just how much energy it takes simply to exist day-to-day in the wake of such a tragedy. Yet, it is not wallowing. It is survival. It is love. It is the necessary, grueling process of finding a way forward while holding tightly onto the person who has been lost.

As a Licensed Professional Counselor, Caffrey now recognizes how common it is for well-meaning individuals—including trained mental health professionals—to mislabel the natural manifestations of grief as wallowing. However, grief operates as a full-body experience. It disrupts thoughts, overstimulates the nervous system, strains relationships, and shatters a person’s fundamental sense of self. It requires compassion, patience, and gentleness, rather than judgment or arbitrary timelines.

This personal and professional ordeal taught Caffrey a profound lesson: grief is an intensely individual journey, and no outside observer has the right to dictate or judge how another person walks it. Taking the time to grieve, to feel deeply, and to remember is not just important; it is essential. For her family, it formed the absolute first step toward healing, regardless of how exhausting or agonizing the path was.

For anyone who has ever been told that their grief resembles wallowing, Caffrey’s message is clear: your grief is valid. Your love is valid. The time and space you require to feel it do not represent weakness—they demonstrate courage. Granting yourself that permission may ultimately stand as one of the most loving choices you can make for yourself, your family, and the child you will always carry in your heart.

Melissa Caffrey continues to carry the memory of her son, Colten, in all that she does. Through her writing, travel, and community initiatives like "Colten’s Tokens," she works to walk alongside other grieving families, offering comfort, connection, and the enduring reminder that the lives of our children—messy, beautiful, and real—continue to shape us forever.