How L.M. Montgomery’s Anne of Green Gables Transformed a Mother’s Perspective on Parenting and Homeschooling
For generations, readers have found themselves captivated by the spirited, red-headed orphan of Prince Edward Island who changed the lives of everyone at Green Gables. For Jamie C. Martin, editor of Simple Homeschool, that influence began at the age of twelve. Spending hours under the spell of Lucy Maud Montgomery’s classic creation, Martin discovered more than just a captivating story; she found a blueprint for her future. The adventures shared with Anne—known famously with an “e”—planted seeds that would later blossom into a life defined by adoption, a deep love for literature, a career in writing, and an unapologetic embrace of starry-eyed dreaming.
Reflecting on those formative years, Martin admits a profound debt to the literary heroine. Throughout her teens and early adulthood, she revisited the entire Anne of Green Gables series, devouring nearly every other title she could source from Montgomery’s bibliography. The author’s unique voice simply resonated deeply.

Years later, however, that relationship with Montgomery’s work evolved. As a newly married adult, Martin turned the pages of all five volumes of The Selected Journals of L.M. Montgomery. For serious fans of the fictional red-head, these journals offered a starkly different reality—one of grown-up entries balancing profound joy with deep sorrow, and happiness sitting side-by-side with heartbreak. It was a revelation that challenged Martin, leaving her uncertain whether she could ever view the optimistic world of Anne Shirley through quite the same lens.
Yet, as Martin would soon discover, Anne and her creator still had valuable lessons left to impart.
Faced with the daily realities of raising her own children, Martin encountered a piece of literary wisdom suggesting that readers should approach classic books—those that have shaped generations—with a specific, personal question in mind. Now reading Anne of Green Gables through the lens of a parent of three, Martin posed a pivotal query: What can a parent truly learn about raising children from this timeless novel?

The answer she uncovered was both surprising and liberating, offering a counter-cultural perspective in a world often obsessed with immediate behavioral correction: loosen up and let maturity do its work.
In the beloved novel, a young Anne Shirley is a perpetual catalyst for mischief. From accidentally getting her best friend Diana Barry drunk on homemade raspberry cordial to falling off a roof’s ridgepole, dyeing her hair an unfortunate shade of green, and spinning elaborate falsehoods to entertain her peers, Anne tests the patience of her adoptive guardians. She also possesses a fierce temper, famously demonstrated when she shatters a slate over Gilbert Blythe’s head after he dares to mock her red hair. Even when Gilbert attempts to make amends with a candy heart bearing the message "You are sweet," Anne coldly drops it to the ground and grinds it to powder beneath her heel without a single glance.
Yet, despite this tumultuous behavior, the stern and tense Marilla Cuthbert—who adopted Anne alongside her gentle brother Matthew—gradually softens. In the wake of the broken slate incident, Marilla takes the advice of a neighbor and grants Anne a reprieve from the rigid environment of the village school. Instead, Anne learns her lessons at home, handles her daily chores, and spends quiet autumn twilights playing with Diana.

Beneath the dramatic flair, the sharp tongue, and the endless scrapes, lay genuine genius: boundless imagination, fierce creativity, high intelligence, and unyielding character. These traits simply required time to find their proper expression. In due season, that chaotic energy blossomed into brilliance.
This journey of maturation mirrors insights found elsewhere in educational literature, such as the book Unschooling Rules: 55 Ways to Unlearn What We Know About School and Rediscover Education. As noted in the book’s chapter on maturation solving problems, the truth is that maturation itself is magic. Irrational teenagers inevitably grow into rational adults, and calmness and focus eventually return. Childhood is naturally filled with periods of equilibrium and disequilibrium, and children operate on their own internal clocks that frequently refuse to align with the rigid structures imposed around them.
For modern parents and homeschoolers, this realization poses a challenging question: Has the pressure of education made caregivers overly tense or unnecessarily stern? Letting maturity do its work means trusting the underlying process, relaxing amidst the daily mischief, finding humor in the chaos, and genuinely enjoying the journey of growth rather than rushing toward perfection. As Montgomery’s text subtly reminds readers, a little appreciation often achieves just as much good as all the conscientious upbringing in the world.